We have already reported on how even the GBC chairman has stated that the ISKCON society is 'disintegrating' (please see issue No. 21 - "GBC Special Issue - GBC Chairman Admits ISKCON 'Disintegrating' ").
Now we have the following shocking statement from Abhirama Dasa.
 |
Abhirama Dasa (left) is acting as the Managing Director of the S.M.D.P. (Sri Mayapur Development Project) which is the single most important and expensive project in the history of ISKCON. He is also a Regional Secretary for ISKCON South India, the Chairman of the M.V.T. (Mayapur Vrindavana Trust), and was/is on the board of the ISKCON Foundation. |
However this is what he said recently in a confidential e-mail sent to a co-Temple President of an ISKCON Temple in South India under his charge:
"I am not a fanatical ISKCON man. Actually, I am no longer sure that the institution is a useful preaching tool. In many ways it has become a burden to the preaching of Gauranga's message. It was a sharp sword in the hands of Srila Prabhupada, but has become a dull blunt instrument in the hands of very incompetent and sometimes foolish hands. It is also a focus of envy for many people who are themselves failures and insincere. My interest is not to protect ISKCON at any cost, but to see how to increase people's love for Hari kirtan, and to have faith in Srila Prabhupada. This has meant promoting ISKCON, in the past, because it represented these goals. Nowadays, the actions of some people are gradually separating the mission of Srila Prabhupada from the mission of ISKCON. I am shocked that I should say this, because I never thought it would come to this, but I must now say it."
(Abhirama Das, 15/10/00)
Yet this is the person who has been entrusted with the biggest project in ISKCON's history, and has also been given a whole chunk of India and a lot more besides to look after. Clearly he is just following in his Chairman's footsteps. The malaise therefore obviously runs deep, beginning right at the top and running through all the sections of ISKCON's leadership. Recently His Holiness Bhakti Caru Swami (BCS) also stated the following:
"I don't hesitate to say that things are a mess in our society."
(Bhakti Caru Swami giving Srimad Bhagavatam Class on October 5th in Vrindavana)
So we have a disintegrating society in a mess, which is nothing but a dull and blunt instrument in the hands of very incompetent and sometimes foolish hands, and which is nothing but a burden on the preaching. And this is what ISKCONs' OWN leaders are saying - not us! You would think that with this state of affairs there would be some humility in their attitude towards others.
Unfortunately not! Whilst freely admitting that their leadership has brought ISKCON to the brink of collapse, they still tried to expel the IRM -TWICE - just because we did not wish to surrender to this morally and spiritually bankrupt leadership!
Another example of this double standard can be seen in the same Bhagavatam lecture of BCS quoted above. In this he also says:
"When Srila Prabhupada was here, the spirit was so high; the preaching was going on so strongly. All the temples were full of devotees and so many individuals were just rushing to join this movement. And that is the Sankirtana spirit. We should revive that spirit. When Srila Prabhupada was here, individuals took so much risk; they risked their lives to go to different corners of the world and spread this movement. But unfortunately, we are missing that spirit today. Young devotees, 2 or 3 months in the movement, went out to spread and establish this movement all over the world.
Now when we look back and think, we can say, "what are we doing? Where is that spirit?" what to speak of going out and opening new temples, many of the temples that Srila Prabhupada gave us are empty today. Why? We have to consider this. [...]
So let us try to revive that spirit of Srila Prabhupada's Sankirtana movement. Let us revive the spirit of ISKCON once again. [...]
I'll take the liberty of being very frank and I'll say that our first mistake was in our initiation system after Srila Prabhupada's disappearance.
The mistake was that when Srila Prabhupada left the planet, some individuals took up the responsibility of becoming gurus, and they more or less assumed that to become a guru means to become like Srila Prabhupada; to be a guru means to have the same position as Srila Prabhupada. In doing so, consciously or unconsciously, we obscured Srila Prabhupada's position; we obscured Srila Prabhupada's greatness. And since then, it is a history of losses in our society."
(Bhakti Caru Swami giving Srimad Bhagavatam Class on October 5th in Vrindavana)
Here BCS states that:
We must REVIVE the ISKCON society. He states this 3 times.
He states that this revival must be based on restoring the spirit of how things were pre-77 - i.e. NO CHANGE
He states that the problem in the movement was that we made a mistake in the initiation system in 1977. That this led to Srila Prabhupada's position to be obscured, and that we must re-instate Srila Prabhupada's greatness back into the center of our society.
Now, there is a group that wishes to REVIVE ISKCON back to how things were in 1977 on the principle of No Change. This group also states that we made a mistake in 1977 in our initiation system, and that this has led to Srila Prabhupada's position being obscured and that we must therefore simply promote Srila Prabhupada's greatness to solve this problem. This group is called the ISKCON Revival Movement (IRM).
You would therefore think that Maharaja would have some sympathy with this group - since they are simply trying to the best of their ability to put Srila Prabhupada in the center as he keeps saying we must. Unfortunately no! BCS's response has been simply to support their expulsion - twice! Which again raises the question of just WHO BCS REALLY wants in the center. Because as soon as a group actually DOES try and put Srila Prabhupada in the center they are expelled for doing so. Even if we are putting Srila Prabhupada TOO MUCH in the center, at least we have the same goal in mind, which should bring some support and sympathy - not expulsion.
- And in any case how is it even possible to put Srila Prabhupada TOO MUCH in the center in his OWN society?
This again exposes BCS's pontification regarding the obscuring of Srila Prabhupada's position as being nothing more than double-talk to try and obscure his OWN worship.